Fake Amazon "review penalty" emails, AI flattery and fake book clubs
-
R. S. Breed Founder
Anne R. Allen's January scam roundup is worth reading, mostly because the tactics have got smoother:
https://annerallen.com/2026/01/new-scam-alerts-for-authors/
The ones she flags:
- Fake Amazon "review penalty" warnings. An email pretending to be from Amazon says that from January, books with fewer than 10 reviews will get "reduced visibility and listing restrictions", and offers a paid "Certified Visibility Specialist" to save you. Amazon has no such policy. The point is to make you panic.
- AI flattery. Gushing, specific praise for your book, the kind that names characters and plot points. That used to be a sign someone had actually read it. Now AI can generate it from your book description and reviews.
- Fake book clubs. One version opens with a glowing AI "review" they say Amazon blocked, and asks if you have a Goodreads or BookBub page they could post it on. Reply and you get the pitch: a book club with 100,000 members that wants to feature your book, if you pay.
On the Amazon one: if an email says your account or your book is in trouble, don't click anything in it. Log in to KDP the way you normally do, from your own bookmark, and look. If something is genuinely wrong, that's where you'd expect to see it.
On the flattery: specific praise isn't evidence of anything any more. Unsolicited, gushing, and followed by "we'd love to help you reach more readers" is the pattern. Check the sender's address too. A Gmail account claiming to be a company is a no.
If you've had one of these, report it to Writer Beware. They can only track patterns if people tell them.