Skip to content
bervet
Sign in Join free
Books Advance copies Forum For readers Audiobooks For authors

Look

E-ink reader

Querying or self-publishing? An honest comparison, not a sales pitch

  1. This one gets argued about like a football code. Both paths work for some people and grind others down. Here's how I'd weigh it, without pretending either is obviously right.

    Querying first. What it gets you is an agent who knows which editors want what. If the book sells, the publisher pays for editing, cover, printing and distribution, and you get an advance that you generally don't hand back if sales are soft. Bookshop and library placement is far easier. Some people also just want to be picked, and that's a legitimate reason, not a vain one.

    What it costs you is time, mostly. Querying can take months or years, then there's the sale, then often a year or two more before the book is on a shelf. You give up control of the cover, sometimes the title, the price and the release date. Your cut per copy is smaller than self-publishing, and the agent takes a share of it. And the gate is narrow. Plenty of good books never find an agent, for reasons that have nothing to do with quality.

    Self-publishing gets you speed and control. You decide when it comes out, what it looks like and whether book two follows in four months or four years. You keep a much bigger share of each sale. Genres where readers burn through a lot of books suit it well.

    The cost is that you're the publisher. Editing and covers come out of your pocket up front, and marketing is entirely yours. The income spread is wide, too: a small group does very well, and a much larger group earns pocket money.

    Neither path is a shortcut. Trad has a slow, narrow gate and then someone else does a lot of the work. Self-pub has no gate at all and then everything is your job.

    Some questions that sort it out faster than any argument:

    • Do you want to run a small business, or do you want to write and have someone else handle most of the rest?
    • How long can you stand to wait?
    • Do readers in your genre buy lots of books from the same author, quickly?
    • How much do you care about seeing it in physical bookshops?
    • Can you pay for editing and a decent cover without it hurting?

    It also isn't a lifetime decision. Plenty of authors do both, and plenty have switched in each direction.

Sign in or join to reply.