Getting honest reviews without paying for them
-
R. S. Breed Founder
Reviews are the part of publishing where desperation makes people do silly things. So the things to avoid first, then what tends to work.
Don't pay for reviews. Paying someone to post a review is not the same as paying for a legitimate service that puts your book in front of readers who might choose to review it. The first gets you reviews nobody trusts, and it can get you into trouble with retailers. Read the retailer's own review guidelines before you try anything clever.
Don't swap reviews with other authors either. "I'll five-star yours if you five-star mine" produces exactly the kind of review readers learn to ignore.
And ignore emails claiming your reviews are about to get you into trouble. Anne R. Allen's scam roundup last month included fake warnings that Amazon would penalise books with fewer than 10 reviews, with a paid "specialist" on offer to fix it. Amazon has no such policy. If a stranger emails to say your reviews are a problem and they can fix it, that's a scam, not a warning:
https://annerallen.com/2026/01/new-scam-alerts-for-authors/
What works is slower and less exciting.
Ask at the end of the book. The page right after the last chapter is when a reader who enjoyed it is most likely to act. A short, plain request with a direct link beats a long plea. Don't beg and don't guilt-trip.
Build an advance reader team: readers who get a free copy before launch, with no strings beyond reading it and an invitation to review if they feel like it. Tell them you want their real opinion, and mean it. Some will give you three stars. That's fine. A wall of five-star reviews and nothing else looks suspicious to readers anyway. It's also good practice for them to mention they got the book free.
Go back to people who already liked you. If you have any way of reaching past readers, that's where early reviews for the next book come from.
Pitch reviewers and bloggers properly. Read their submission policies and follow them exactly. Use their name. Accept that most won't reply, because they get far more requests than they can read.
Above all, be patient. Reviews grow with readers, and the ratio of reviews to sales is usually low. A book with a few hundred sales and a handful of reviews isn't broken.
When a bad one arrives, don't reply to it. Not publicly, not privately, not "just to clarify". An author arguing with a reviewer has never once made the book look better.