Skip to content
bervet
Sign in Join free
Books Advance copies Forum For readers Audiobooks For authors

Look

E-ink reader

Getting useful feedback from beta readers

  1. Beta readers can save a book or waste a month. The difference is mostly in who you pick and how you ask.

    Pick for the job. You want a few readers who read your genre heavily, and at least one who doesn't. Genre readers catch broken conventions. The outsider catches the things genre readers forgive out of habit. Friends and family are lovely and nearly useless here, because they're reading you, not the book.

    Don't ask "did you like it?" You'll get "yes" and learn nothing. Ask questions with specific answers:

    • Where did you put it down, and did you want to pick it back up?
    • Which character did you care about least?
    • Was anything confusing? Where exactly?
    • What did you think was going to happen at the midpoint? Were you right?
    • Did you skim anywhere?

    Ask for reactions, not fixes. Readers are brilliant at telling you where something's wrong and often off the mark about how to fix it. "I got bored in chapter twelve" is gold. "You should cut the sister" might not be.

    Then look for overlap. One reader hating a scene is taste. Three readers flagging the same scene in different words is a problem.

    Give them a deadline and a format, too. "Whenever you get to it" usually means never. A short list of questions makes it easier to say yes and easier to finish.

    And thank them properly. Credit them in the acknowledgements if they want that, send them the finished book, and don't argue with their notes. If you disagree with one, just quietly don't take it.

    One more. Don't send it out until you've fixed everything you already know is broken. Beta readers are for finding what you can't see, not for confirming what you can.

Sign in or join to reply.