Series or standalone for your next book? The honest trade-offs
-
R. S. Breed Founder
The standard indie advice is "write in series", and for a lot of genres it's right. But it gets repeated as if it's free, and it isn't.
What a series gives you:
- Read-through. Every reader who finishes book one is a warm lead for book two. You're not finding a new audience each launch.
- Marketing that compounds. One ad, one promo, one price drop on book one can sell the whole run. With standalones you're mostly starting from scratch every time.
- Readers who know what they're getting. In romance, fantasy, mystery and thriller, a lot of readers actively look for series.
What it costs you:
- Book one carries everything. If it doesn't land, books two to five sink with it. You can fix a weak standalone by writing a better next book. Fixing a weak series opener usually means rewriting it or starting another series.
- Commitment. Five books in the same world is a lot of years with the same characters. If you get bored, readers can tell.
- Gaps hurt. Readers forget. Some wait until a series is finished before they start. Kindle's AI "Recaps" will fill them in on earlier books whether you like its summary or not (authors report there's no way to opt out), which tells you how common the problem is.
The middle ground gets underrated:
- Connected standalones. Same world or town, different lead each book, each one complete. Read-through without the trap of book one having to work.
- A planned trilogy or duology. A known ending is easier to sell to readers who've been burned by series that never finished.
If you do go series, my suggestion is to have book two drafted, or close to it, before book one comes out. The gap between one and two is where most of the momentum leaks.
And know your ending before you start. Not every scene, but where it lands. "I'll figure it out by book four" is how series stall at book three.
For those writing standalones by choice: what's kept you away from series?